Alkalinity / Calcium

Home        Index

 I have grouped these two together, because they are inexplicably linked chemistry wise and need to be considered as a whole. 

A common mistake made in this hobby is monitoring and adjusting calcium levels without paying much attention to alkalinity levels.  This is somewhat understandable given that the need for calcium in the tank, especially a high demand tank is fairly obvious.  What is not so obvious is that the requirement to maintain good alkalinity levels is even higher and the interaction that exists between calcium levels and alkalinity levels inexplicably tied together.  I am a firm believer that alkalinity levels are more critical than calcium levels, so boosting calcium while letting alkalinity do its own thing is not the way to go.  There is also the unfortunate fact that calcium and alkalinity levels tend to counteract each other where increasing calcium forces alkalinity to decrease and vice versa, even if this is not what is desired. 

Normal seawater has a calcium level of about 380 and an alkalinity level of 2.8.  These levels work fine in low and some moderate demand tanks where there is not a lot of calcium consuming inhabitants.  I often see new hobbyists with a couple of mushrooms in a new tank who think that need to be dosing calcium.  That generally is just wasted money and effort.   In tanks that have fast growing calcium consuming critters such as SPS corals and clams, it is generally better to maintain elevated levels of both calcium and alkalinity.  This tends to improve growth, coloration and general health of the specimens.  Calcium levels in the range of 400 to 450 are preferred with up to 500 being acceptable. Alkalinity levels of 3.2 to 4.5 is preferred.  Some have reported good results using the more normal 2.5 to 2.8 alkalinity level of normal saltwater which is what most salt mixes mix up to, but I have had my SPS corals tend to brown out under those conditions.

 Water changes alone are sufficient to maintain normal seawater levels (depending on what level the salt mix provides) in low and some moderate demand tanks.  In order to elevate the levels or even maintain normal seawater levels in high demand tanks requires that the levels be supplemented somehow.  This is where it can get to be a little tricky.  There are five basic ways to accomplish this task

bullet Kalkwasser – a dry alkaline powder that is mixed with water and dripped
bullet2-part supplements – liquid supplements that provide both a calcium and alkalinity component in balanced proportions.
bulletLiquid supplements -   Individual supplements that can be mixed and matched to try to accomplish the goal
bulletDry supplements - Individual supplements that can be mixed and matched as above.
bulletCalcium Reactor – High tech machinery approach.

 Kalkwasser 

Kalk is the oldest and one of the still commonly used means to maintain calcium levels and alkalinity.  Kalk is a dry powered form of lye that is mixed with water to create a solution rich in calcium that has a very high pH.  This solution is allowed to settle and the clear portion of the solution is siphoned off and dripped into the sump slowly so as not to upset the pH of the tank water.  This is usually dipped in overnight when pH of the tank tends to be lowest.

 Many experienced reef keepers swear by the use of Kalk.  My results have been less than satisfactory and I don’t recommend it for several reasons. 

bulletThe powdered form of Kalk is very caustic and has to be handled carefully.  Being a fine powder, it tends to wander about more than it should.
bulletThe solution must be mixed.  There are many formulas from shaking it up in a capped bottle to using a powerhead, to using a powerhead on a timer.  Everyone swears by their specific method.  Whatever method is chosen must exclude as much air as possible to prevent precipitation.
bulletHalf the users state that the solution must be allowed to settle for an extended period and only the clear portion of the solution used in the tank, others maintain that you must use the milky version to get adequate results.  Group A says that using the milky version causes precipitation in the tank.
bulletThe solution has the tendency to develop a crust on it that should not be added to the tank, which only complicates the process more.
bulletThe amount that can be added is limited to the amount of makeup water that the tank needs.  Many users try to accelerate evaporation so that they can add more Kalk, which is another thing to worry about.
bulletMany users who can’t keep their levels adjusted with the Kalk alone supplement with other additives anyway.
bulletMy personal experience has been that Kalk seems to often cause a drop in Alkalinity, which is not a good thing.
bulletIt is easy to accidentally overdose and suddenly shift the chemistry of the tank water, especially in small tanks.

 The main good thing about Kalk is it is relatively cheap compared to most other options.  There is also evidence that Kalk can help to participate phosphates out of the water. 

If you want to try Kalk, go for it, but keep a close eye on your tank readings.  I won’t attempt to give a formula to use, because I was never very successful using it, so I obviously don’t know what the correct formula is.

Kalkwasser.jpg (40567 bytes) Kent Marine Kalkwasser

 Common form of Kalkwasser

 
2 Part Liquid Supplements
 

There are two common 2-part supplements on the market.  B-Ionic and C-Balance.  These both come as liquid additives in 2 parts (hence the name).  One part is to add calcium and trace elements, the other part is a buffer/alkalinity component.  These additives seem to work fairly well in low to moderate demand tanks where they are used to maintain existing levels.  In high demand tanks, they sometimes seem unable to handle the demand and the levels fall, even when large quantities of the additives greater than the recommended maximum are used.   As the quantity is increased, there can be a tendency for these supplements to cause the sand to clump and form a solid rock like structure which is not a desirable thing to have happen.  2-part supplements elevate salinity, so when using large quantities, you will need to keep an eye on the salinity and adjust it occasionally.  The other downside to the 2-part supplements is that the cost can get very expensive when you are going through it fast.  I recommend 2-part supplements in low to moderate demand tanks where the amount required is moderate and you are only trying to maintain water parameters and not adjust them.  They are probably the easiest supplement to use.

CBalance.jpg (43525 bytes) C-Balance 

Two part Calcium/Alkalinity supplement

BIonic.jpg (38791 bytes) B-Ionic 

Two part Calcium/Alkalinity supplement


 Liquid Calcium Supplements

 There are a number of liquid calcium products on the market.  Most have names like ‘turbo’ or similar.  The main issue with these products are that they do not take alkalinity into account and a common mistake is to measure calcium only and using one of these products to adjust to the level you want without realizing the alkalinity levels are dropping.  Simple fact is that alkalinity level is more critical than the calcium level.  Usage of these products requires that you monitor alkalinity as well and use a buffering product to maintain alkalinity levels.

CalciumSupplement.jpg (45678 bytes) Reef Pure Concentrated Calcium Supplement

Common form of liquid calcium supplement


Dry Calcium/Alkalinity products

 These are what I used to use in my high demand tank.  Using these products, I was able to adjust and maintain whatever levels I wanted to without clumping the sand or having the pH get out of whack, so I have become a big fan of them and recommend them highly. 

I used 'Reef Builder' to maintain alkalinity and 'Reef Advantage' for Calcium, magnesium and strontium supplementation.

Being in dry powder form, they need to be dissolved in water before adding to the tank.  I personally mix my buffer in the AM and drip it in before I go to work.  I mix the calcium component and drip it in before I go to bed at night.  The addition of the two components should be separated by at least 30 minutes per the Seachem literature, probably to prevent precipitation.  I drip it into where my tank overflow is in the sump so that it gets quickly mixed into the water.    My own 70 gallon high demand tank required about 7tsp. of Reef Builder and 5tsp. of Reef Advantage each day to maintain my Alkalinity around 4 meq/L and calcium around 450ppm.  Obviously the amount appropriate for any particular tank must be determined through testing of the water.  

ReefAdvantage.jpg (40040 bytes)

Seachem Reef Advantage

Calcium, Magnesium, Strontium supplement

ReefBuilder.jpg (43470 bytes) Seachem Reef Builder

Alkalinity supplement

ReefCalcium.jpg (47777 bytes) Seachem Reef Calcium

Polygluconate calcium.

Calcium Reactor 

This is the new gadget on the block.  It is composed of a cylindrical tube containing aragonite chips.  Water is pumped through the tube and aragonite media in a recirculating fashion.  Carbon dioxide from a compressed air tank is then slowly bubbled through the water and aragonite column.  The carbon dioxide creates an acidic condition that dissolves some of the aragonite into the water.  A small dribble of water is released from the reactor and allowed to drain into the sump. The water exiting the reactor is rich in calcium and helps to maintain the alkalinity of the system.  Depending on the reactor media used, Strontium and Magnesium are also maintained at proper levels. The water leaving the reactor has a low pH.  Some systems utilize a 2nd stage on the reactor which serves the purpose of dissolving additional minerals with the same amount of CO2, thus conserving CO2 consumption and perhaps more importantly, it helps to raise the pH of the effluent so that it has less effect on the pH of the tank.

Calcium reactors are becoming very popular on high demand systems.  Although they require some dialing in, once setup they are relatively low maintenance.  You no longer have to mix supplements by hand every day and since they run continually, the tank parameters will be maintained at a more consistent level than once a day additions can achieve.  It also has the benefit that it will not cause calcium deposits on pumps, etc. as the other methods can.

So what’s the downside?  Primarily cost.  Calcium Reactor systems require a reactor chamber, a pressure regulator and a compressed air tank, plus CO2, aragonite media, a bubble counter to see how fast the CO2 is being dispensed, etc.  A typical system will run about $500 - $600.  Of course, the other additives tend to be fairly expensive over time whereas the calcium reactor is more of a one-time hit.  The other potential negative to a calcium reactor is that it can depress the pH level of the tank.  This can generally be controlled fairly easily.

I would highly recommend a calcium reactor for high demand SPS tanks.  It may be overkill for low to moderate demand tanks.

CalcReactorEquipment.jpg (40743 bytes) Here is a basuc calcium reactor setup.  The cylinder on the left contains the aragonite media, a recirculating pump and a small bubble counter which allows you to control the rate of CO2 injection.  The tank on the right is a CO2 tank with a regulator.  This is a 10# tank which is on the large side.  If cabinet space is limited, smaller 5# and 2# bottles are available.
CalcReactor.jpg (52247 bytes) This shot shows the reactor above in its operating location under the tank stand.
Sump225_6_01.jpg (60214 bytes) Here is a sump shot that shows the 2nd stage that I added to the reactor.

 

Home        Index