Tank Log:  Dialing It In

Home

Main Journal Previous Entry

Next Entry

 

After getting the tank initially setup, there were a number of things which did not pan out at first.  These included:

bullet

Microscopic bubbles in the tank

bullet

Excessive overflow noise

bullet

Excessive  temperature

bullet

Low pH

On top of that, there were a couple of things that I needed to get dialed in such as:

bullet

Need to dial in Skimmer

bullet

Need to dial in Calcium Reactor

 

Bubbles in the tank

I had taken some care with my sump design to put in several baffles to prevent bubbles from getting into my return pumps, but it obviously wasn’t working.  Very small bubbles were being generated on the overflow side and these were small enough that my baffles had no affect on them.  They happily swept through all my baffles, past my settling area and into my return pumps even thought the sump is 4 feet long.  The issue with the bubbles is primarily cosmetic, but they can also cause air pockets to form under shelf type corals and cause areas of die-off.

 I first tried several things that were not very effective.

bullet

Putting foam sheets around skimmer output helped some, but not enough.  These did help to keep splashing down and are needed in any case for a high volume skimmer like the Bullet 2 that I have on the tank.

bullet

I placed a large fine mesh filter bag over overflow tubing.  This also seemed to help some, but not enough.

bullet

I placed fine foam filter blocks over the intakes of the two return pumps (MAG 9.5’s).  This reduced the problem a little, but tended to cause bursts of bubbles to be pumped into the tank rather than a steady flow, probably as the bubbles collected on the foam and then blurped into the intake all at once.  I also am not a big fan of having mechanical filtration devices in the tank, so I removed these.

After looking closer at the problem, it became obvious that the main source of fine bubbles was from the output of my skimmer.  I found that by readjusting my skimmer to have a higher water level in the reaction chamber, the bubbles decreased dramatically on its output and problem was solved!  Way too simple, but effective.

 

 Excessive overflow noise

 My two MAG 9.5 return pumps output about 1500GPH combined.  This amount of water flow through the overflow and into the sump created quite a racket.  The filter bag on the overflow tubing helped to minimize the rushing noise in the sump as did increasing the water level in the sump.  I had purposely left the overflow tubing above the sump water level to prevent gurgling noise, but I found that placing the output below the water level quieted the noise considerably, reduced splash and did not induce any new noises.  My sump was now quiet, but I was still left with a loud rushing noise through the overflow itself.  Going against conventional wisdom, I decided to add a ball valve to the overflow line.  The idea was to restrict the overflow enough to raise the water level in the overflow box so that it would reduce the waterfall affect.  I slowly closed the valve until the water level started to drop in the sump, which indicated that I had an imbalance between my overflow and my returns.  I then slowly opened the valve just until the water level started to rise again in the sump, meaning that my overflow could handle just a little more water than my return pumps were putting out.  This caused my overflow line to mostly fill with water and quieted the waterfall noise down to almost zero. 

The downside to this approach is that you have somewhat of a balanced state between your overflow and return.  If something upsets this balance, there may be a tendency to run the sump dry.  Normally, you want the overflow to have significantly greater capacity than your returns to prevent any such problems.  I will keep an eye on this arrangement to make sure that it does not induce any new problems.  Simple but effective.

  

Excessive Temperature

 I had made the decision to run this tank cooler than on my previous tank.  I had been using a temperature range of 80-84 degrees.  I noticed that many of my corals did not seem happy at the higher temperatures, especially xenia.  Also, the best reef tanks I have seen have been run at cooler temperatures of 75-78 degrees even though the current trend is toward higher temps.  I made the decision to try to maintain mine in the range of 78-80F as a compromise.   I built the light hood with 4 muffin fans that blow air in from the back and direct it across the surface of the water.  I discovered that with nowhere for the hot air to go, the tank was getting warmer than I liked, so I made a couple of changes that seemed to fix things.  

bullet

One is that I leave one end door on the hood open.  This allows a place for the hot air to vent out of the hood.  Not very elegant, but works.  Long term, I may plumb an exhaust fan through the garage wall behind the tank to draw hot air out of the hood.  

bullet

The second thing I did was to place a large clip-on fan over the sump.  This fan is directed directly on the water in the sump.  The idea is to increase evaporation and hence the cooling effect.  All the fans come on with the MH lighting.

bullet

I have also started to leave one end door open on the bottom cabinet to keep the sump area cooler by about 4-5 degrees which helps the overall cooling affect and allows the sump fan to be more effective.

bullet

Currently I am keeping our air conditioner on 70F during the hot days to ensure things stay reasonably cool.

These changes have allowed me to keep the temperature within the range I am looking for, but I may eventually invest in a chiller.  We will see how things fare as we get into the hot summer months.  Although the house is air conditioned, the room the tank is in is at one end of the house and it does not get much cross circulation.  Another easy change I will probably make is to add an exhaust fan to the bottom of the tank cabinet to exhaust the warm humid air from around the sump rather than leave an end door open.  I already provided a hole for this purpose, now I just need to add a fan and wire it in.

SumpFan.jpg (40320 bytes) Here is the fancy sump fan which has been stole from my wife.  It is on a timer to come on with the MH lighting.  Note the large temperature monitor on the back wall.  This has proven to be a very accurate and convenient device.  It also has over temp and under temp alarm capability.

 

 Low pH

 This is an area I have never had a problem with before.  The tank runs at about 8.05 -  8.1 during the day and drops to as low as 7.75 at night.  I am using a PinPoint pH meter to monitor it.  While it is normal for the pH to drop at night, I would really like to see it stay above about 8.2 during the day and about 7.9 at night if possible.  

To determine the cause of the low pH, I placed some water in a cup and ran an airstone in it for about 15 minutes.  The pH went from 7.8 to 8.05.  This indicated that the culprit was an excess of CO2, probably partially due to the calcium reactor.  However, switching the calcium reactor off for a night did not seem to have any affect.  I have implemented the following changes:

bullet

Built a second stage for my calcium reactor.  This is simply a 4" diameter, 20" long acrylic tube that holds calcium reactor media.  A small 3/8" tube in the center hooks up to my calcium reactor output and directs the reactor effluent to the bottom of the second stage where it filters up through the reactor media where it drains out a small drain.  The idea is that the CO2 in the effluent is further consumed in the second stage which should both increase pH and alkalinity/calcium content.  This seemed to work pretty good and increased the pH of the effluent from about 6.8 to about 7.3.

bullet

The second thing I did was to add an airstone to the sump where the second stage is located.  Again, this is intended to drive off excess CO2.  

These two changes increased the pH from about 8.05 to 8.2 within a half day.

CRSecondStage.jpg (33256 bytes) Here is the homemade 2nd stage for the calcium reactor.  It is made of a 20" section of 4" acrylic tubing with some round pieces providing a base and a cap.  A 3/8" tube down the center directs the effluent to the bottom of the chamber.
CRSecondStageBase.jpg (34266 bytes) Here is a close-up of the base.  This shows small holes that have been drilled into the tube which allow the effluent to drip out into the reactor media
CRSecondStageOutput.jpg (26753 bytes) Here is a close-up of the top.
CRSecondStageOperation.jpg (41968 bytes) Here is the second stage in the sump.  The red line is bringing the effluent from the calcium reactor.  Notice the air pump and air stone which also helps to drive off the excess CO2.  I am going to go to a larger wand style air stone to increase this capability.

  

Dialing in the skimmer

The skimmer I selected for this tank is a Precision Marine Bullet 2.  This is a high powered skimmer based upon the Beckett air injector rather than a normal venturi value.  These skimmers process much greater amounts of water and air than normal skimmers and are suppose to require less maintenance.  I am powering my skimmer with a MAG18 submersible pump which puts out 1800GPH at zero head.  I initially started with the air intake set to wide open and adjusted the water level in the skimmer reaction chamber to the specified height in the chamber.  I was unsuccessful in getting a reasonable foam with these settings.  Either I got no foam at all, or I was dumping a gallon of wet foam out every hour.  I discovered through trial and error that by adjusting the water level higher in the column and decreasing the amount of air, I achieved smaller, more stable bubbles, which gave me a much better skimming action.  The skimmer now skims about 1 gallon a day, which I consider about ideal for this size of tank. 

SkimmerDialIn.jpg (39634 bytes) Here is a picture of the skimmer after it has been dialed in.  The water level is about 1/2 way up the larger chamber.

 

 Dialing in the Calcium Reactor

The calcium reactor I selected was a Precision Marine CR622.  This is their larger reactor that holds about 15lbs of media.  Dialing it in was fairly simple.  After setup, I adjusted the output affluent to be a broken stream (between a drip and a steady stream) and set the bubble count to a little more than 1 bubble per second.  This has worked to give me a calcium level of about 500 ppm and alkalinity level of about 4.0 meq/l in this first week of operation.  I will continue to monitor and fine tune the reactor over the next few weeks.

Home

Main Journal Previous Entry

Next Entry